The 10 Best Sandwich Toasters as of June 2026

How we ranked these sandwich toasters

Each pick earns a score out of 10 from weighted criteria:

Performance (35%) — how well each sandwich toaster does its core job.
Value (25%) — quality and features for the price.
Build & reliability (20%) — materials, longevity and warranty.
Features (20%) — meaningful extras that improve the experience.

At a glance: top 10 compared

Swipe across to see all columns, including Amazon links →

#	Sandwich Toasters	Score	Best for	Type	Approx. Price	Amazon links
1	Breville VST082 Ultimate Deep Fill	9.0	Best overall	2-slice deep fill	$50	View Price
2	Breville VST041	8.6	Best 4-slice	4-slice deep fill	$55	View Price
3	Lakeland Deep Fill	8.5	Best value	2-slice deep fill	$35	View Price
4	George Foreman 25041	8.5	Best grill-style	Flat grill	$40	View Price
5	Tower 3-in-1	8.4	Best multi-plate	Interchangeable plates	$40	View Price
6	Dualit Sandwich Toaster	8.4	Best build	2-slice	$60	View Price
7	Russell Hobbs 3-in-1	8.3	Best budget multi	Interchangeable plates	$30	View Price
8	Salter Deep Fill	8.3	Best budget	2-slice deep fill	$25	View Price
9	Global Gourmet 4-Slice	8.2	Best cheap 4-slice	4-slice	$35	View Price
10	VonShef Deep Fill	8.2	Best simple	2-slice deep fill	$25	View Price

The full ranking

Best overall

Breville VST082 Ultimate Deep Fill

9.0Our number one pick.

Breville's Ultimate Deep Fill makes thick, generously filled toasties with deep cavities, a strong seal that locks fillings in and even browning, the toastie maker most people should buy. It only does two at a time, but the deep-fill results and build are exceptional.

Toasting: 9.2Sealing: 9.4Cleaning: 8.8Value: 9.0

Pros

Deep, generous fillings
Strong cut-and-seal
Even browning

Cons

Only two at a time
Fixed plates

Check price on Amazon≈ $50

Best 4-slice

Breville VST041

8.6A superb runner-up.

The Breville VST041 toasts four deep-fill sandwiches at once, ideal for families and batches, with the same reliable seal and browning. It is larger to store, but the capacity and results are excellent.

Toasting: 8.8Sealing: 9.0Cleaning: 8.6Value: 8.8

Pros

Four toasties at once
Deep-fill plates
Reliable seal

Cons

Larger footprint
Heavier

Check price on Amazon≈ $55

Best value

Lakeland Deep Fill

8.5Rounds out our top three.

Lakeland's Deep Fill toastie maker delivers thick, well-sealed sandwiches with non-stick plates at a friendly price, backed by UK support. It is plainer than premium models, but the results and value are excellent.

Toasting: 8.6Sealing: 8.8Cleaning: 8.6Value: 9.2

Pros

Deep fillings
Good seal
Great value

Cons

Two at a time
Basic styling

Check price on Amazon≈ $35

Best grill-style

George Foreman 25041

8.5A standout in the upper half.

The George Foreman 25041 uses flat grill plates that press paninis and toasties flat while letting fat drain away, doubling as a small grill. It seals less tightly than cut-and-seal makers, but the versatility and value are excellent.

Toasting: 8.6Sealing: 8.2Cleaning: 8.8Value: 9.0

Pros

Paninis and grilling
Fat drains away
Easy to wipe clean

Cons

Looser seal than cut-and-seal
Open sides

Check price on Amazon≈ $40

Best multi-plate

Tower 3-in-1

8.4A well-rounded mid-table pick.

The Tower 3-in-1 swaps between sandwich, waffle and grill plates, a versatile one-box snack maker for varied treats. The plates take storage space, but the three-in-one flexibility and value are good.

Toasting: 8.4Sealing: 8.4Cleaning: 8.6Value: 8.8

Pros

Sandwich, waffle and grill
Removable plates
Good value

Cons

Plates to store
Jack of all trades

Check price on Amazon≈ $40

Best build

Dualit Sandwich Toaster

8.4Great value in the middle of the pack.

Dualit's sandwich toaster feels sturdier than most with a stainless body and even heat, a tidy, durable choice that should last. It costs more and does two at a time, but the build and even toasting are good.

Toasting: 8.6Sealing: 8.6Cleaning: 8.4Value: 8.4

Pros

Sturdy stainless build
Even heating
Good seal

Cons

Pricier
Two at a time

Check price on Amazon≈ $60

Best budget multi

Russell Hobbs 3-in-1

8.3A dependable pick if the price is right.

The Russell Hobbs 3-in-1 offers sandwich, waffle and grill plates at a low price, good-value variety for occasional snacks. The build is lighter-duty, but the flexibility and value are good.

Toasting: 8.4Sealing: 8.2Cleaning: 8.6Value: 9.0

Pros

Three plate types
Affordable
Easy to use

Cons

Lighter-duty
Plates to store

Check price on Amazon≈ $30

Best budget

Salter Deep Fill

8.3Solid, if outshone by pricier rivals.

The Salter Deep Fill makes thick toasties with non-stick plates and cut-and-seal edges at a low price, a sensible budget pick. It is basic, but for cheap deep-fill toasties it is good value.

Toasting: 8.4Sealing: 8.4Cleaning: 8.4Value: 9.2

Pros

Deep fillings cheaply
Cut-and-seal plates
Compact

Cons

Basic build
Two at a time

Check price on Amazon≈ $25

Best cheap 4-slice

Global Gourmet 4-Slice

8.2A budget-friendly option worth a look.

The Global Gourmet 4-slice toasts four sandwiches at a budget price, handy for families who want quantity for less. The seal isn't as deep as premium makers, but for cheap batch toasties it is good.

Toasting: 8.2Sealing: 8.2Cleaning: 8.4Value: 9.0

Pros

Four at once cheaply
Non-stick plates
Family-friendly

Cons

Shallower seal
Lighter build

Check price on Amazon≈ $35

Best simple

VonShef Deep Fill

8.2Rounds out our top ten.

The VonShef Deep Fill keeps things simple with non-stick deep-fill plates and ready lights at a low price, an easy everyday toastie maker. It is basic, but for simple, affordable toasties it does the job well.

Toasting: 8.2Sealing: 8.4Cleaning: 8.4Value: 9.0

Pros

Simple and cheap
Deep-fill plates
Compact

Cons

Basic features
Two at a time

Check price on Amazon≈ $25

Frequently asked questions

What's the best of the sandwich toasters in 2026?

Our top overall pick is the Breville VST082 Ultimate Deep Fill, which leads on our combined score for performance, value and features. The Breville VST041 and Lakeland Deep Fill are excellent alternatives depending on budget and needs.

How did we choose these?

We weight performance, value, build quality and features, drawing on hands-on use and independent testing. See the methodology box above for the full breakdown.

Are these prices accurate?

Prices are approximate UK figures at the time of writing and change frequently. Click through to Amazon for the current price.

The bottom line

If you just want the best sandwich toasters without overthinking it, the Breville VST082 Ultimate Deep Fill is our top recommendation — it earns the highest overall score for performance, value and features. Have a look at the current price and see what you think.

Check price on Amazon ≈ $50

Our top picks at a glance

Breville VST082 Ultimate Deep Fill

Lakeland Deep Fill

Breville VST041

You might also like

How we ranked these sandwich toasters

At a glance: top 10 compared

The full ranking

Breville VST082 Ultimate Deep Fill

Pros

Cons

Breville VST041

Pros

Cons

Lakeland Deep Fill

Pros

Cons

George Foreman 25041

Pros

Cons

Tower 3-in-1

Pros

Cons

Dualit Sandwich Toaster

Pros

Cons

Russell Hobbs 3-in-1

Pros

Cons

Salter Deep Fill

Pros

Cons

Global Gourmet 4-Slice

Pros

Cons

VonShef Deep Fill

Pros

Cons

Frequently asked questions

The bottom line

⚖️ Build your own comparison